What Is the Most Expensive House in Scarsdale, NY?

A Luxury Market Overview by Five Corners Properties

Scarsdale, NY is known for its beautiful homes, prestigious neighborhoods, nationally ranked schools, and proximity to New York City. It is no surprise that Scarsdale consistently ranks among the most desirable — and most expensive — real estate markets in Westchester County.

Buyers often ask us: “What is the most expensive house in Scarsdale right now?”

While the top listing changes as new luxury homes hit the market or record-breaking sales close, Scarsdale’s highest-end properties typically range between $8 million and $10 million+, depending on size, location, and features.

At Five Corners Properties, we monitor these luxury listings daily. Here’s a look at what defines the very top of Scarsdale’s real estate market.

🏡 Recent Examples of Scarsdale’s Most Expensive Homes

To understand what “most expensive” means in Scarsdale, it helps to look at recent standout listings and sales — all representing the peak of luxury living.

1. 42 Mamaroneck Road – Listed around $9.85 Million

A stunning new-construction estate featuring over 8,600 square feet, elegant finishes, grand entertaining spaces, and nearly every modern amenity imaginable. This home reflects the upper range of Scarsdale luxury pricing.

2. 1 Duck Pond Road – Sold near $9.85 Million

One of the highest recorded Scarsdale sales in recent years, this property offered exceptional scale, custom architecture, and a premier location. A true statement home.

3. 17 Heathcote Road – Sold around $8.5 Million

Located in the coveted Heathcote neighborhood, this property combined classic Scarsdale charm with luxury updates and extraordinary curb appeal.

These examples show that Scarsdale’s top-end homes consistently fall within the $8M–$10M+ range — with new construction often setting the newest records.

🌳 What Makes a Home Reach Scarsdale’s Highest Price Points?

Scarsdale’s most valuable homes typically feature:

✔ Exceptional Size & Craftsmanship

8,000–10,000+ square feet
Custom architecture
High-end luxury finishes

✔ Premier Location

Large estates in neighborhoods like Heathcote, Fox Meadow, Murray Hill, and Quaker Ridge
Generous property sizes
Quiet residential streets with prestige appeal

✔ Luxurious Amenities

Chef’s kitchens
Spa-like primary suites
Wine rooms
Home theaters
Expansive outdoor living spaces
Smart-home technology

✔ Rarity

Very few homes in Scarsdale meet this level of design, size, and exclusivity — making the ones that do highly sought after.

📈 What This Means for Scarsdale Buyers & Sellers

For Buyers:

If you're shopping in the upper tier of the market, expect homes between $8M and $10M+ to represent the very top end of Scarsdale’s available inventory. These properties are often shown privately and marketed discretely—something Five Corners Properties specializes in.

For Sellers:

If you own a large estate or newly constructed luxury home, the recent record sales show strong demand at the highest price points. Strategic pricing and premium marketing are essential to capturing top value.

For All Homeowners:

Understanding the peak of the market helps frame the entire value spectrum in Scarsdale. Luxury sales lift neighborhood values and influence pricing trends across 10583.

🔍 Want to See Today’s Most Expensive Homes in Scarsdale?

We monitor luxury listings daily and can provide you with:

  • A current list of the highest-priced homes available

  • Private or early-access opportunities

  • Market data and neighborhood insights

  • Comparable luxury home analyses

Simply contact us — we’ll curate a list tailored to your goals.

Contact Five Corners Properties

📞 Call/Text: 914-297-9282
🌐 FiveCornersProperties.com
📩 info@FiveCornersProperties.com

 

Let us show you the very best of Scarsdale luxury living.